This
was an incident that I happened to observe at a hospital in Singapore.
The patient, an old man from China,was in such a critical situation that
he needed to be admitted right away to the medical ward.Patient was assigned
to bed number 4. However, the patient's family member was not satisfied
and consistently requested for a bed change.The reason was that number 4 was a homonym for “death” in Chinese.The nurse
manager explained to the family members that the hospital then was
experiencing a severe shortage of beds due to high patient load and it
would take as soon as 2 days to get another bed available. It was
imperative to let patient have treatment at the ward right away.
Surprisingly enough, patients’ family members agreed to forgo bed
number 4 and let the patient stay in the emergency department until
another vacant bed was ready.
Due
to such procrastination,the patient was in coma for 3 weeks and would not
likely to recover. On top of that, the family was then in a state of financial difficulty.Therefore,
the doctors suggested a humanitarian death as an ultimate solution for
him. However, again, the medical team encountered one significant issue : the cultural barrier.The
family members took their suggestion in such a negative way that they
became so agitated and requested for a transfer to another hospital.
The
medical staff tried to explain their viewpoint but to no avail.
Finally, the patient was shifted to another hospital as per request.
Analysis :
The
above story might sound very awkward to some of us .How could one
allow the life of his/her beloved one to be endangered due to such
ridiculous matter of a bed number ? However,strictly speaking, number
four has been well-known to be an unlucky number in Chinese culture.Due
to that, many numbered product lines skip the "four". For example, Nokia
phone does not have a series number starting with 4. Some buildings skip
floor 4 or replace the number with the letter "F", particularly in
heavily Asian areas. And there is absolutely no table number 4 in a
Chinese wedding dinner....Assumed that you were educated by your parents
with such strongly fixed mind against number 4, chances are you would not
know other better way to behave than the above Chinese family did.
Another
underlying issue was the delicate and sensitive topic of death. Death
has been such a taboo across cultures that it leads to conversational
unease or even disruption.After all, number 4 was not
well-received because it implies death.The extent in which people
accept death and how much they are willing to talk about it varies from
culture to culture. In this case, the Chinese family had rather extreme
preconceptions about it. As a consequence,such ideas have hindered
them from saving their own family member from the hand of death.
Hello Heather,
ReplyDeleteI can understand where the Chinese family was coming from. Death is a very taboo subject in the Chinese culture and we don't to talk about it openly especially during auspicious occasions like weddings and Chinese New Year.
This might be because Chinese people cherish longevity and prosperity, and death would be the total opposite of that.
Here are some mistakes I spotted:
1) The patient, a Chinese old man from China, >> The patient, an old man from China (I think by saying he is from China would imply he is Chinese)
2) Patient was assigned to bed number 4 >> The patient was assigned to number 4.
3) It was imperial to let patient have treatment at the ward right away.>> (I'm not sure about the use of the word imperial here, i think you meant imperative?)
-Gwen
Hi Gwen
DeleteThank you for spotting out the errors in my post!! I have fixed it according to your contributive criticism.It definitely helps. :)
Yes, i meant "imperative" , not "imperial".:)
Hi Heather,
ReplyDeleteI felt that the flow of your writing in this post was pretty smooth. To be honest, when I first saw your blog post, I thought it was quite lengthy and I felt a little reluctant to read it. I am so glad that I did not succumb to my laziness or I would have missed out on the interesting topic that you brought up in your post. Moreover, the smooth transitions from one discussion to another made it very easy to read.
Moving on to the example in your blog post, I think that how one views the incident really depends on the existing prejudice that one has. A neutral person will likely put the blame for the patient’s condition on the patient’s family who make seemingly ridiculous demands and caused medical help to arrive later than it could have been. On the other hand, the patient’s family who were already very biased against the number “4” might actually view this outcome as a belief that proved to be right. That is, because the patient had taken the bed with the inauspicious number “4”, therefore he went into a coma. Hence this might further reinforce their prejudice against this number.
Hi Jestina
DeleteYes, I totally agree with you that one's viewpoints on certains issue are constrained by his own preconceptions.
in addition, your hypotheisis is interesting. I never thought of it. Perhaps thing was meant to happen that way so that the patients'family somehow realised that the patient 's death was primarily attributed by their narrow conceptions after this incident.
Hi Heather:D
ReplyDeleteYou have brought forth 2 very interesting issues. 2 issues that I am certain are bound to come up again in such a scenario. I feel that the context is all the more interesting given that it is in a hospital, where a lot more is at stake than just people's pride, respect etc. In fact, doctors need to be interculturally sensitive in communicating with the different cultures. There are numerous articles out there highlighting the main cross cultural problems being faced by doctors.
Issue #1
A culture's perception towards superstition and how they hang on to it even in the face of death of a family member. I suppose the family was all the more wary of the number 4 given the context of the situation and keeping in mind what was at stake.
In such a scenario, I feel that the hospital could have made some better arrangements. Perhaps shift someone who is not as superstitious when it comes to the number 4?
Alternatively, they could have temporarily renamed the room number. Maybe changed it to 3B or 5A for the time being.
As for issue #2, I would appreciate if you could clarify it a little. You mentioned that the doctor suggested a humanitarian death. Could you clarify what this is? And the doctor suggested this as opposed to? Pulling the plug? Or are you saying that the issue of death should not even have been raised. Because if that was the case then, it would have been close to impossible to communicate with the family if they were going to be so difficult.
Awaiting your reply:D
Hakeem
Hi Hakeem
ReplyDeleteShifting the bed with someone else who is fine with number 4 could be an excellent idea that the medical tem could have tried out!
Anyway,here what I want to emphasize were the negative emotions associated with number 4 . with suchfixed mind, even if the bed was renamed, the family members probably would not be able to buy the idea too since the had seen where the bed was located!
Humanitarian or humane death is method to allow the patient to die with a minimum of pain or anxiety. This is generally achieved by giving the patient( particularly those with severe injuries , brain death and impossibility to recover from coma) intravenously with an overdose of barbiturate.
Hope the above helps to clarify your questions.
Thank you for putting your ideas in this scenario.
Cheers!
This is a very appropriate, well focused post, Heather. You do a fine job telling the story and in describing the cultural variable at play. As Hakeem mentioned, an issue related to the way the family was adhering to their demands for a bed change was their strong belief in the "superstition" connected to the number 4. While that particular belief is not a cultural universal, it is found throughout Asia. I saw many instances in Japan connected to the same number. What about in Vietnam?
ReplyDeleteThe only thing that surprised me in the case that you describe is that in Singapore -- with its decidedly Chinese roots an current population -- the hospital in question would be oblivious to such a belief. Why do you suppose?
In any case, thank you for this very fine short essay!
Hi Heather,
ReplyDeleteYou brought a very interesting point on superstition. I think it is the older generation of chinese that are more superstitious when it comes to the number four. On the other hand, most of the younger generation do not seem to care so much. Maybe in another decade or so this superstition will fade away and no longer exist in our society.